Monday, August 17, 2009
JOIN US FOR: Pray the Devil Back to Hell: A Special Screening and Panel Discussion on August 24th at 7 PM.
Thursday, August 13, 2009
Independent Prosecutor MUST be Given Broad Mandate to Investigate Senior Officials Who Authorized Detainee Abuse
In response to this news, Human Rights USA, along with a number of other human and civil rights groups, have called for the Attorney General to broaden the scope of the investigation to include senior government officials responsible for directing, approving, or authorizing the use of such techniques.
Since 2004, Human Rights USA has been calling for the appointment of an independent prosecutor to investigate senior officials' involvement in detainee abuse and the extraordinary rendition program.
Read our full Press Release below (also available here).
Press Release
August 13, 2009
Human Rights
Sources close to the Attorney General claim that he is close to making a decision on the appointment of an independent prosecutor. But, according to these sources, rather than seek an investigation into the full range of crimes committed by former administration officials, Holder is only considering cases in which CIA interrogators exceeded the techniques approved by administration attorneys. That news is discouraging.
By now, it is apparent that lawyers for the Bush administration wrote legal memoranda approving techniques that clearly violate the Geneva Conventions and
The Bush administration was widely criticized for blaming widespread detainee abuse on a handful of “bad apples.” Despite the fact that more than 600 civilian and military personnel have been implicated in detainee abuse, investigations have yielded few prosecutions: less than 50 people have been held to account, all of them low-ranking military or civilian personnel. Even then, many of the punishments meted out have been mild relative to the crimes committed.
An investigation into crimes committed by low-level CIA interrogators is an attempt to again blame detainee abuse on just a few “bad apples.” This kind of limited investigation does not reach the heart of the problem: the administration authorized tactics that violated accepted standards of domestic and international law.
The Attorney General must appoint an independent prosecutor to investigate those who authorized and approved these abuses, not only those who committed them.
To ensure that an investigation is not hampered by artificial limitations imposed for political reasons, the independent prosecutor must be given: a broad mandate to conduct an investigation into the origins of the detainee abuse program; wide latitude to pursue any prosecutions deemed necessary as a result of the investigation; freedom to operate outside the day-to-day control of the Justice Department; sufficient funding to carry out the mandate; and ample time, with possibility for extension, to conduct the investigation.
Attorney General Holder must not allow former administration officials to enjoy impunity for their crimes. To do so would be to condone serious transgressions of some of the most basic and fundamental human rights protections our laws afford. Investigating and prosecuting these abuses affords justice to the victims and their families, deter future administrations from committing these crimes, and send a message to the rest of the world that
I SEE WHAT? A Discussion of the International Court of Justice (ICJ) and a quick look at the International Criminal Court (ICC)
Sadly, not quite forty years later, in 1984, the United States withdrew itself from the compulsory jurisdiction of the ICJ – a court it helped create. (“Compulsory jurisdiction” means that if a dispute involving the US was submitted to the Court, the United States would be required to subject itself to the Court's authority.) In 2005, the United States terminated its acceptance of the Court’s jurisdiction over disputes arising under the Vienna Convention on Consular Relations, a treaty that specifically named the ICJ as the venue for settling such cases.
States that have not agreed to compulsory jurisdiction can still come before the Court in two ways 1) as signatories to a treaty that specifically names the ICJ as the venue to settle disputes, (approximately 300 treaties refer to the Court in settling disputes); and 2) on a case-by-case basis. Finally, as a court of “dual jurisdiction,” the ICJ not only has the authority to decide contentious cases between States, but may also provide advisory opinions on legal questions at the request of the organs of the U.N. or other specialized agencies.
In 1999, under the auspices of the Convention, Germany sought to halt the imminent execution of Walter LaGrand, a German national being held in the US. In response, the ICJ issued a provisional measure calling on the United States to ensure LaGrand’s death sentence was not carried out, but LaGrand was executed the same day. Two years later, Germany asserted that the United States had 1) violated its legal obligation under the Vienna Convention to give consular officers access to imprisoned nationals; and 2) failed to comply with the ICJ’s provisional measure.
By Nadia Ben-Youssef, Legal Intern, International Justice Project
Thursday, August 6, 2009
To Prosecute or Not to Prosecute: the Weight on Eric Holder's Shoulders
Although the ICC was created in 2002, the United States has yet to sign and ratify the Rome Statute, the treaty that established the ICC. However, recent remarks attributed to Secretary of State Hillary Clinton and Attorney General Eric Holder evidence a shift in attitude, one that could mean greater U.S. support for the international tribunal specifically, and accountability for human rights more generally. But it could also mean greater diplomatic entanglements with other countries.
In response to a question she received from a student during a talk at the University of Nairobi in Kenya today, Secretary Clinton remarked that it is a "great regret" that the United States is not a party to the ICC, adding: "I think we could have worked out some of the challenges that are raised concerning our membership by our own government, but that has not yet come to pass." Somewhat optimistically, she noted that the United States has "supported the court and continue to do so."
Meanwhile, over in the Justice Department, it was recently reported that Attorney General Eric Holder is leaning towards appointing an independent prosecutor to investigate and, where warranted, prosecute former Bush administration officials responsible for detainee abuse and torture. What do these two events have in common? Secretary Clinton's comment about the United States' continuing support of the ICC could carry more weight than she intended, depending on how the Attorney General plays his cards.
While unrelated to Secretary Clinton's remarks, Attorney General Holder's ultimate decision regarding the appointment of an independent prosecutor could have a profound effect on the United States in the long run, both with respect to its relationship with the ICC and its diplomatic relations with other countries. To understand the interconnectedness of the two worlds that the Attorney General and Secretary of State inhabit, consider the following scenarios:
If the Attorney General declines to prosecute the allegations of serious human rights violations against former Bush administration officials, the ICC could, as a court of last resort, exercise jurisdiction over the case under limited circumstances. Jurisdiction would only extend to cases where, for instance, the state on whose territory the crime was committed refers the matter to the ICC Prosecutor. Although this possibility seems unlikely, there are a great number of countries in which abuses amounting war crimes or crimes against humanity were allegedly committed. Those countries include the following ICC member states:
Afghanistan (which became a party to the ICC on 10 Feb. 2003); Albania (31 Jan. 2003); Austria (28 Dec. 2000); Bosnia-Herzegovina (11 Apr. 2002); Bulgaria (11 Apr. 2002); Canada (7 July 2000); Croatia (21 May 2001); Cyprus (7 Mar. 2002); Denmark (21 June 2001); Estonia (30 Jan. 2002); Finland (29 Dec. 2000); France (9 June 2000); Germany (11 Dec. 2000); Greece (15 May 2002); Hungary (30 Nov. 2001); Iceland (25 May 2000); Ireland (11 Apr. 2002); Italy (26 July 1999); Jordan (11 Apr. 2002); Lithuania (12 May 2003); Malta (29 Nov. 2002); Netherlands (17 July 2001); Norway (16 Feb. 2000); Poland (12 Nov. 2001); Portugal (5 Feb. 2002); Romania (11 Apr. 2002); Spain (24 Oct. 2000); Sweden (28 June 2001); Switzerland (12 Oct. 2001); and the United Kingdom (4 Oct. 2001).
A complaint filed by any one of those 30 countries could bring former U.S. officials before the very court the Bush administration so desperately sought to marginalize.
ICC jurisdiction would also extend in cases where the Security Council refers a matter to the ICC Prosecutor (a less likely proposition, given the United States' influence on the Council). Under an equally unlikely scenario, the United States, as a non-party to the ICC, could accept the Court's jurisdiction only with respect to a particular crime in question. These scenarios are all, of course, purely hypothetical at this point. But the ICC is young: just because U.S. citizens have not been called to account before the Court does not mean that it can't happen.
The Attorney General's decision whether or not to appoint an independent prosecutor could also affect a criminal complaint currently pending before a Spanish court. In early May, human rights lawyers filed a complaint in Spain's National Court, alleging that six Bush administration officials (the "Bush six") created a legal framework for torture against U.S. detainees, in violation of international human rights law. The Spanish judge in charge of the complaint, Judge Eloy Velasco, said that before he decides whether to open his own investigation in Spain, he plans to ask the United States whether it intends to investigate such abuses. Attorney General Holder stated his intent to cooperate with whatever investigation might take place in Spain.
Under the principle of universal jurisdiction, a foreign country can exercise criminal jurisdiction over a case involving the commission of serious human rights crimes by U.S. citizens only if the U.S. government refuses, or fails, to take action. Attorney General Holder's decision to appoint an independent prosecutor could, for that reason, thwart any efforts by other countries to seek accountability themselves.
Conversely, the Attorney General's decision not to prosecute former U.S. officials could also have serious consequences overseas, but for different reasons. The United States' refusal to prosecute serious human rights violations would open up the door for another state to prosecute those crimes under its universal jurisdiction statute. Judge Velasco, or any other foreign judge considering such a complaint, could then exercise universal jurisdiction over the case. Should any of the named defendants in the case travel to the country in which the complaint is being investigated, they risk arrest, trial, and punishment overseas. Even if they step foot in a country other than the one in which the complaint was filed, they could still be extradited to the prosecuting state in order to stand trial.
The decision whether or not to appoint an independent prosecutor is no doubt a difficult one. Whatever choice he makes, Attorney General Eric Holder's decision is sure to make waves at home, across the Atlantic, and throughout history.
Tuesday, August 4, 2009
POSTPONED: "Torture: Too High a Cost"
ROAD TO RATIFICATION: The Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities
Watch the Human Rights USA blog for updates on national efforts to ratify these treaties. Over the coming months, we will post details about each of the conventions, the legal implications of ratifying human rights treaties, and how the treaties play out in the courtroom when we bring legal actions to enforce the rights the treaties are intended to protect.